SEC Crypto Custody Proposal Tests Self-Custody Against Investor Safeguards
The SEC proposal would let advisers self-custody crypto only when permitted custodians are unavailable, while industry and investor-protection groups split over whether the guardrails are workable.
The Proposed Change
The Securities and Exchange Commission has proposed a tailored custody framework for crypto assets held by registered investment advisers and regulated funds, a move intended to clarify how investment firms may handle client crypto assets while updating reporting and recordkeeping requirements. The proposal would permit crypto assets to be held in self-custody in limited circumstances, allow state trust companies to serve as custodians, and leave the public comment period open for 60 days after the proposing release appears in the Federal Register. (U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission; sec.gov)
Why Self-Custody Is Narrow
The self-custody permission is narrower than the phrase may suggest. Commissioner Hester Peirce's statement says the term does not describe investors holding their own assets; it describes an asset-management practice in which advisers may hold client or regulated-fund crypto assets only under specified conditions. A threshold condition is the adviser's determination, before taking custody and quarterly afterward, that no permitted custodian is available for the crypto asset. (CoinDesk; U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission)
State Trust Companies
The proposal also expands the custody path through state trust companies, but Peirce's account says advisers or regulated funds would need a reasonable basis, before engagement and annually afterward, to believe the state trust company is authorized by the relevant state banking authority and has written policies and procedures designed to safeguard crypto assets and related cash from theft, loss, misuse and misappropriation. (CoinDesk; U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission)
Regulatory Framing
SEC statements cast the proposal as a compliance route rather than a blanket exemption. Commissioner Mark Uyeda said the proposal presents a workable path without compromising custody-rule protections, while also recognizing that adviser self-custody creates an inherent conflict of interest and leaves the adviser's fiduciary duty in place. That framing matters because CoinDesk reported the rule would first require that an adviser cannot find a qualified custodian ready to take the assets, a scenario an SEC official described as likely unusual after implementation but possible for a newly launched token. (coindesk.com; U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission)
Support From Asset Managers
AIMA, an asset-management association, praised the proposal as a move toward more workable custody rules for advisers holding crypto assets for clients. Its statement said clear custody rules are an essential investor safeguard, that the proposal would open routes for safeguarded self-custody and state-trust-company custody while keeping the private-fund annual-audit route, and that AIMA would work with members to test whether the balance protects investors while giving managers enough flexibility to implement investment strategies. (acc.aima.org)
Investor-Protection Objections
Better Markets took the opposite view. In a statement by Benjamin Schiffrin, the group said traditional securities custody requires investment advisers to use qualified custodians such as banks or broker-dealers, and it criticized the SEC for proposing to let advisers themselves maintain custody of clients' crypto asset securities. Better Markets argued that the change subjects investors to the high risk of loss the SEC exists to prevent and also objected to allowing state trust companies to custody crypto assets. (Better Markets | Transparency. Accountability. Oversight.)
Separate Buyback Guidance
The custody proposal is distinct from SEC staff guidance on crypto buybacks. The Division of Corporation Finance's crypto-asset FAQs say they are staff views, not SEC rules, have no legal force or effect, and do not create new obligations. The FAQ answer cited in the earlier article is also narrower than saying buybacks are never securities-law evidence: it concerns an issuer announcement of a non-security crypto asset buyback program where the crypto system is functional and has no central party. (sec.gov)
Legal Uncertainty
Decrypt's reporting shows why the buyback guidance remains contested. It reported that a buyback announcement can still cross a line if an issuer pitches it as generating yield or returns, and it quoted criticism that teams could keep building, support prices with buybacks and enjoy public-investment benefits without giving holders shareholder-style rights. The custody proposal therefore lands alongside a broader SEC effort to define crypto compliance paths, but neither the custody rule nor the buyback FAQ is final law until the relevant process produces binding authority.
What To Watch
The practical question for advisers is not whether self-custody becomes freely available, but whether an adviser can document custodian unavailability, meet periodic review duties, satisfy fiduciary obligations, and show that any chosen state trust company has both authority and safeguarding policies. The practical question for investors is whether those guardrails reduce the loss risks identified by critics or merely move custody risk inside the advisory firm. The comment period is the next formal venue for that dispute. (Better Markets | Transparency. Accountability. Oversight.; U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission; U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission; U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission)